Demand for Slant : How Abstention Shapes Voters ’ Choice
نویسندگان
چکیده
Political commentators warn that the fragmentation of the modern media landscape induces voters to withdraw into “information cocoons” and segregate along ideological lines. We show that the option to abstain breaks ideological segregation and generates “cross-over” in news consumption: voters with considerable leanings toward a candidate demand information that is less biased toward that candidate than voters who are more centrist. This non-monotonicity in the demand for slant makes voters’ ideologies non-recoverable from their choice of news media and generates disproportionate demand for media outlets that are centrist or only moderately biased. It also implies that polarization of the electorate may lead to ideological moderation in news consumption. Thus, our results cast doubt on the oft-prophesied, imminent demise of mainstream media and may help to explain recent empirical ndings showing less ideological segregation in news consumption than predicted by extant theories. JEL Codes: C7, D7, D8.
منابع مشابه
Demand for Slant : How Abstention Shapes Voters ’ Choice of News Media ∗
Binary decision theory predicts that voters prefer information sources whose biases conform to their own. We argue that voting is not a binary decision problem and that introducing abstention generates “cross-over” in news consumption (i.e., conservative voters consulting liberal media– and vice versa). Specifically, the option to abstain induces voters with considerable leanings towards a part...
متن کاملThe Impact of Media Bias: How Editorial Slant Affects Voters
We investigate how editorial slant—defined as the quantity and tone of a newspaper’s candidate coverage as influenced by its editorial position—shapes candidate evaluations and vote choice. We avoid various methodological pitfalls by focusing on a single Senate campaign in a single market with two competing, editorially distinct newspapers. Combining comprehensive content analyses of the papers...
متن کاملThe voter who wasn't there: Referenda, representation and abstention
We analyze single binary-choice voting rules and identify the presence of the No-Show paradox in this simple setting, as a consequence of specific turnout or quorum conditions that are included in actual rules. Since these conditions are meant to ensure a representative outcome, we formalize this concern and reach our main result: no voting rule can ensure representation if abstention is possib...
متن کاملMajority decisions when abstention is possible
Suppose that we are given a family of choice functions on pairs from a given finite set. The set is considered as a set of alternatives (say candidates for an office) and the functions as potential “voters.” The question is, what choice functions agree, on every pair, with the majority of some finite subfamily of the voters? For the problem as stated, a complete characterization was given in Sh...
متن کاملAbstention in Dynamical Models of Spatial Voting
We consider a model of platform adaptation in spatial voting focussing on the effect of abstention on the stability of the mean voter equilibrium. Two distinct approaches for modeling abstention are explored: (1) voters abstain if party platforms are too similar to each other and (2) voters abstain if both party platforms are far away from their ideal points.
متن کامل